Redsafe
  1. Home
  2. Insights
  3. Quality
Quality2 min readRedsafe Engineering

NDT for welded steel and piping: VT, PT, MT, UT and RT compared

The five common non-destructive testing methods for welds, what each finds, where each is used, and how NDT extent is specified.

NDT technician performing phased-array ultrasonic testing on a pipe butt weld, probe on couplant, instrument screen showing a scan
Representative image

Non-destructive testing (NDT) checks welds without damaging them. No single method finds every defect, so specifications combine methods and set an extent of testing for each weld category.

The five common methods

Method What it finds Typical use
VT — Visual testing Surface profile, undercut, porosity, cracks open to the surface, dimensions Every weld, before any other method
PT — Penetrant testing Fine surface-breaking cracks and porosity Non-magnetic materials such as stainless steel, and root checks
MT — Magnetic particle testing Surface and near-surface cracks Carbon steel fillet and butt welds, lifting lugs
UT — Ultrasonic testing Internal lack of fusion, cracks and inclusions; thickness Thicker sections and structural butt welds; phased array (PAUT) produces a recordable image
RT — Radiographic testing Internal porosity, slag and incomplete penetration Pipe butt welds, producing a permanent film or digital record

Extent of testing

Codes and specifications set how many welds are tested, not just how. Process piping codes, for example, define different examination requirements for different fluid service categories, from random spot examination up to 100% examination for severe cyclic or high-risk service. When a spot test fails, the code usually requires additional welds by the same welder to be tested.

Qualified people, qualified procedures

NDT results are only as reliable as the technician and the procedure. Technicians are normally certified to ISO 9712 or an equivalent scheme at the level the work requires, and work to written NDT procedures.

The record

NDT reports should reference the weld number on the weld map, the method, procedure, acceptance criteria, result and technician. They form part of the quality control pack handed over with the item.

At Redsafe

On a referenced Sasol vessel and silo blender package, Redsafe achieved 100% first-pass NDT results. Read the case study or see fabrication and welding.

Related capabilities
Keep reading

Related articles.

Overhead view of piping isometric drawings on a table with weld numbers highlighted, a calculator, a tape measure and a short pipe offcut
Piping5 min

Diameter-inches explained: how piping contractors measure and price welding

Welding supervisor at a workshop desk marking up piping isometrics with a weld map and a tablet
Fabrication5 min

Estimating welding man-hours for piping and structural steel

Consumables store: low-hydrogen electrode drying oven, wire spools, gas cylinders on a trolley, storeman issuing electrodes to a welder
Fabrication4 min

How to estimate welding consumables: weld metal volume, deposition efficiency and electrode quantities

Start a project

Send us the scope.

Drawings, a bill of quantities or a description of the problem. An engineer reviews every enquiry and comes back to you directly.

WhatsAppMessage us
BaseKya Sand, Randburg
Call WhatsApp Start a project